A Chronic Absenteeism Rate of 125 Percent Is Still an Official Federal Statistic

Documentary-style flat-lay on a federal education statistician's desk. Center: a printed spreadsheet labeled "EDFacts Chronic Absenteeism Report" with one row clearly highlighted in red showing "Chronic Absenteeism Rate: 125%" with a hand-circled note reading "??". To the left, a whiteboard diagram showing the flawed formula — "Chronically Absent (full year) / Enrolled (Oct. 1 snapshot)" — with an arrow pointing to a box labeled "IMPOSSIBLE." A sticky note reads: "Known limitation — documented in appendix." A second sticky note reads: "Pennsylvania: 62 of 63 shared-time schools implausible." A coffee-stained guidance memo sits nearby labeled "EDFacts Data Note: Rates may be inflated." A calculator shows "125%" on its display. The mood is bureaucratic dysfunction dressed up as official data. Muted institutional palette — cream, federal blue, red flags, gray, fluorescent light.

There are two kinds of numbers a federal agency can publish. There is the kind that is wrong because the world is complicated and measurement is hard. And there is the kind that is wrong because the agency built the measurement out of two pieces that were never designed to fit together, and kept publishing it anyway. The Department of Education’s chronic absenteeism rates, the only nationally comparable figures on how many American students are missing significant school, are the second kind. Some of them exceed one hundred percent. The Department knows this. It has known for a while. It has decided, as of this year, not to fix it.

The Government Accountability Office’s review of Department data found implausible chronic absenteeism rates, meaning more students reported chronically absent than were recorded as enrolled, in roughly 2.5 percent of schools nationwide using 2022 to 2023 data, the most recent year available. That is GAO’s word, implausible, chosen with the sort of restraint auditors reserve for things that would otherwise require a stronger one.

Two Clocks, One Number

The mechanics are almost embarrassingly simple once laid out. To calculate a chronic absenteeism rate, the Department divides the number of students identified as chronically absent by the number of students enrolled. The chronically absent count is tallied over the entire school year, students who missed ten percent or more of the days they were enrolled, at any point, for any reason. The enrollment count, on the other hand, is captured on a single day, October 1, and never updated. A student who enrolls in November and racks up chronically absent status by May is counted in the numerator of a rate whose denominator was frozen months before that student ever showed up.

In a stable school with a fixed roster, this barely matters. In a school where students are constantly moving in and out, it produces nonsense. GAO’s own illustrative example makes the point better than any explanation could. A school with 100 chronically absent students and 80 enrolled on October 1 reports a chronic absenteeism rate of 125 percent. Using the number of students who were actually enrolled for at least 10 days over the full year, the same school’s real rate is 66 percent, itself alarming, but at least a number that exists inside the bounds of arithmetic. Somewhere between those two figures sits the actual scale of a real problem, and the Department has chosen to publish the version that cannot possibly be correct.

The Department’s own EDFacts documentation contains a data note warning users that rates calculated this way may be inflated. Which is one way of describing a nationally reported statistic that occasionally exceeds the maximum value a percentage is capable of holding.

The Schools Where It Breaks Hardest

The mismatch is not evenly distributed, and where it concentrates tells its own story. Schools identified for Comprehensive Support and Improvement, meaning the lowest performing schools in the country, the ones this data is supposed to help states target, had implausible rates in nearly 13 percent of cases, compared to about 2 percent for non-CSI schools. These are precisely the schools where students change addresses and schools most often, and precisely the schools where accurate absenteeism data would matter most for deciding where to send help.

Shared-time schools fare even worse. These serve students who split their day between two buildings, often for career and technical education programs, and can end up double-counted as absent in one building while attending the other. More than 30 percent of shared-time schools had implausible rates, against under 2 percent everywhere else. The variation between states is its own indictment of data quality. Delaware, Idaho, Maryland, Missouri, North Carolina, and Rhode Island each report zero shared-time schools with implausible rates. Pennsylvania reports implausible rates in 62 of its 63 shared-time schools, 98 percent. States are not disagreeing about a close call here. They are simply not reporting the same phenomenon the same way, because nobody at the Department has told them how. Education, GAO notes dryly, provides states with guidance on how to report enrollment for shared-time students, but not on how to report their chronic absenteeism, an oversight nobody apparently noticed until an outside auditor went looking.

A Known Limitation Is Still a Limitation

In 2024, the Department began requiring states to report the number of students enrolled over the full school year, the same timeframe already used for the chronic absenteeism count, which would have let it calculate a rate that actually means what it claims to mean. It abandoned that effort before completion. GAO’s report ties the reversal to staffing reductions inside the Institute of Education Sciences, whose workforce fell by more than 85 percent between the end of 2024 and the end of 2025.

In its formal response to GAO’s draft recommendation on this point, the Department did not dispute any of the math above. It disputed the need to change anything, writing that the mismatch is “a known limitation that is already documented,” and that it has chosen to keep working with the data elements it already collects rather than add reporting burden on states. GAO’s counter is worth sitting with, since states already have to identify which students were enrolled at least 10 days in order to calculate the chronically absent count required for EDFacts in the first place. The number the Department is declining to collect is a number states are already generating internally to comply with an existing requirement. The Department is not avoiding new work. It is avoiding one additional column in a spreadsheet the states are already filling out, and calling the result a documented limitation rather than an unfinished fix.

Documenting a flaw is not the same as correcting it, and a data note buried in a technical appendix does not travel with the number once a school board, a state legislature, or a local reporter pulls it out to argue that a particular school is failing its students at a rate of 125 percent. The number will be believed. It just will not be true.

Source: U.S. Government Accountability Office, K-12 Education: Actions to Improve Oversight of Key Federal Programs and Address High Chronic Absenteeism (GAO-26-107920, September 2026). Related: Eighteen Billion Dollars, and Nobody Assigned to Watch It, and The Department Started Fixing Its Data, Then Fired the People Fixing It.


Advertisements

Discover more from Bureaucracy Times

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.