A bill would require the Forest Service to convey 14 acres of national forest to a named company at appraised market value. CBO’s estimate puts a small number on the federal budget effect, but not on the property.
The Congressional Budget Office’s estimate for a bill transferring national forest land to a Wisconsin company fits neatly into one line: direct spending would decrease by less than $500,000, with no effect on federal revenues.
That is a useful budget figure. It is not the price of the land.
H.R. 3937, the Wabeno Economic Development Act, would require the Forest Service to convey about 14 acres in the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest to Tony’s Wabeno Redi-Mix, LLC, if the company offers to buy the property at its appraised market value. The parcel includes improvements and mineral rights. The company would also pay the costs of the appraisal, survey and any federally required environmental analysis. The House-passed text.
The House passed the bill in July 2025. It was placed on the Senate legislative calendar in July 2026 and has not been enacted. The bill would require the Forest Service to complete its appraisal within 300 days of enactment. The Senate committee’s legislative listing.
A Budget Score Is Not a Property Appraisal
CBO’s July 2025 estimate said the amended bill would reduce direct spending by less than $500,000 and would not affect revenues. Its table linked to a more detailed CBO estimate for the prior Congress’s version of the bill, H.R. 7072. That earlier estimate put the bill’s direct-spending effect somewhere between a $500,000 reduction and a $500,000 increase over the relevant budget periods. CBO’s July 2025 floor-week estimate and the earlier estimate for H.R. 7072.
Neither figure tells the public what the parcel is worth.
CBO’s estimates measure potential federal budget effects. The bill’s appraisal is a separate process, intended to determine the property’s market value. The company would pay that amount if it chooses to make an offer after the appraisal is approved. The legislation itself contains no dollar value for the land.
That distinction matters. A small estimated change in federal spending is not evidence that the property is worth little, just as a future market-value appraisal would not by itself explain how the government decided the transfer served the public interest.
CBO also cautioned that it had limited time to review bills scheduled for House consideration under suspension of the rules. In that process, debate is limited and amendments are prohibited. CBO said it may be able to identify whether bills affect spending or revenues even when it lacks time to estimate the magnitude. CBO described the limits of its review.
One Local Transfer, One Nationwide Review
The bill pairs the parcel conveyance with a broader directive to the Interior Department. DOI would have to review federal permitting for stone, sand and gravel development, including average approval timelines, duplicative steps, possible streamlining measures and economic effects. The department would then publish its findings and recommendations. The bill’s text.
The two provisions concern the same industry, but they raise different questions. The land transfer is a specific transaction involving a named company and a particular parcel. The permitting review could influence how federal agencies evaluate aggregate development across federal lands.
USDA testimony described the parcel as approximately 14 acres on the Lakewood-Laona Ranger District, near the town of Wabeno. The department said the land contains upland northern hardwood forest and raised minor technical concerns about the bill. USDA’s testimony to the Senate.
That information gives the public a starting point. It does not establish the parcel’s appraised value, how the Forest Service will account for the mineral rights, or what the buyer plans to do with the property.
The Questions the Bill Leaves for the Agencies
The appraisal will be central to the transfer. The Forest Service will need to determine how the parcel’s location, improvements and mineral rights affect market value, and what assumptions the appraisal uses. The agency will also need to explain what environmental analysis or resource surveys are required before the conveyance.
The permitting review raises another set of questions. Which agencies and stakeholders will help shape it? What data will support the reported average timelines? Will DOI publish the methods and evidence behind its conclusions, along with the final report?
Those are reporting questions, not proof of wrongdoing. The bill calls for a market-value appraisal and requires the buyer to pay specified transaction costs. The public still needs enough information to assess how the appraisal was conducted and how the national permitting recommendations were developed.
CBO has supplied a budget estimate: a reduction in direct spending of less than $500,000. The property’s price, the supporting appraisal and the evidence behind the broader permitting review remain matters for the agencies to document.
Sources: CBO’s July 2025 estimate; CBO’s earlier estimate for H.R. 7072; bill text; USDA testimony; Senate legislative status.
