The NLRB Announced a Backlog Victory and Left Out the Dismissals

Flat editorial illustration in muted navy, burgundy, beige, and institutional gray. A large stack of case files sits on a desk. Half the stack has been stamped DISMISSED in red. A government official holds up a trophy celebrating progress. A clipboard nearby shows a chart going down. Deadpan, dry newspaper editorial illustration style. No text.

On October 30, the National Labor Relations Board issued a press release announcing favorable case processing data for fiscal year 2026, with the obligatory reminder that more work remains.

The favorable data is real, as far as it goes. The trouble is where it stops.

A Banner Year, by the Agency’s Own Account

Start with what the NLRB says. When General Counsel Crystal Carey was sworn in on January 7, 18,221 cases were sitting in field offices awaiting investigation and a decision. Nearly 10,000 of them were more than six months old.

As of the release, 10,684 of those cases had been “moved to determination.”

The agency also shifted about 3,500 charges between regional offices in May. Of those, 1,810 have reached determination.

On the Board side, the release reports 390 decisions in contested cases, the most since 2015. It says 591 cases were pending when a quorum returned in January, 208 more arrived, 507 were decided, and 292 remain.

Some context the release skips. The agency’s own FY 2025 performance report shows the Board issued only 86 contested-case decisions that year. A law firm’s summary noted that former Board members said many decisions were already drafted and waiting for new members to arrive.

That suggests part of the 390 reflects a held-up pipeline being released. The release does not say how many were drafted before the new members arrived.

The release is also quiet on why the Board stopped functioning. It says the Board lost its quorum at the end of January 2025, in the passive voice. Another Proskauer summary counts the quorum’s return as coming eleven months after the firing of Member Gwynne Wilcox.

The Word Doing All the Work

“Moved to determination” sounds like resolution. It is not.

By the agency’s own budget justification, a regional director decides after investigation whether a charge has merit. A dismissal is a determination. So is a finding of merit that leads to a settlement or a complaint.

The release does not say how many of the 10,684 landed in which pile.

The NLRB’s own disposition dashboard offers a hint. For fiscal 2026 it shows 8,561 charges dismissed. That is 49 percent more than the 5,748 in FY 2025, and more than double the 3,923 in FY 2024.

As a share of all closures, a calculation we ran from the dashboard’s figures, dismissals made up 47.1 percent in FY 2026. In every year from FY 2017 through FY 2025, they ran between 21.9 and 30.2 percent.

Settled or adjusted cases fell to 4,921, or 27.1 percent of closures. That is the lowest count and the lowest share in the ten years shown. Withdrawals also hit a ten-year low in count, at 4,469.

Dismissals and withdrawals combined came to 71.7 percent of closures, against 55.6 to 61.6 percent in prior years.

Total closures were 18,172, fewer than the 19,012 in FY 2025. Whatever the dashboard shows, it does not show a surge in closures.

A Closed Case Is Not a Resolved One

Before anyone treats that as proof of anything, the caveats.

Dismissals are ordinary business. The NLRB’s own site says more than half of all charges are withdrawn or dismissed. A rise in dismissals is not, by itself, evidence that something went wrong.

Some of it may be housekeeping. An independent analysis from NLRB Edge found a September 2025 spike in dismissals of old bargaining charges, averaging 3.2 years old. It appeared tied to a new status-report requirement for charges deferred to arbitration.

That spike landed in FY 2025, so it cannot explain FY 2026 by itself. The requirement recurs twice a year, and whether the March 2026 cycle produced more dismissals is not shown.

The dashboard also records outcomes, not reasons. It cannot separate a charge dismissed for lacking merit from one dismissed because a charging party missed a deadline.

That distinction matters because of the intake changes. In late December 2025, then-acting General Counsel William Cowen introduced a docketing protocol. New charges now wait on an unassigned list until the charging party submits a timeline, documents, and witness information. Carey, once sworn in, voiced support for it.

The agency says the two-week response period has long been standard practice, and that the standard for dismissing a charge did not change.

Bloomberg Law reported that four union attorneys described regional offices dismissing charges over technicalities or the offices’ own errors. The official who introduced the changes expressed surprise and then disapproval when a union lawyer described the problem to him. Regional employees, Bloomberg also reported, generally welcomed the relief.

Our inference is that part of the FY 2026 rise in dismissals reflects those intake changes. The basis is the timing, since the protocol took effect inside the fiscal year, and Bloomberg’s reporting on dismissals for failure to cooperate. The reasoning is that a screening step added at the front end should produce more early closures.

Timing is not causation. No public data yet separates screening dismissals from merit dismissals.

A Center for American Progress analysis points the same direction. From January 2025 through April 29, 2026, it found the NLRB dismissed 34.7 percent of union-filed charges against employers, 14.2 points above 2024. For worker-filed charges against employers, the figure was 67.4 percent, up 10.7 points.

CAP is a progressive think tank. Its method excludes withdrawals, its window ends in April, and it measures a different period than the dashboard. It corroborates a direction. It does not establish a cause.

Counting Is Not the Same as Fixing

The release reports progress on the January 7 cohort. It does not give the total pending today. Charges filed since January are not in that count.

The resources picture comes in three sizes. The release says field staffing has shrunk 50 percent over two decades and notes a $294 million budget for FY 2026. Carey told a House subcommittee in June the agency was 31 percent understaffed compared with ten years ago. CAP puts the field-office shortfall at 23 percent and counts eight hires against more than 150 departures in 2025.

Those are different baselines, not necessarily contradictions. The agency’s request for more money is on the record either way.

The release also says filings fell 4.27 percent and credits the shutdown. It adds that pre-shutdown data pointed to an increase. Whether workers and unions filed fewer charges because of the shutdown, or for other reasons, is not established.

Inquiries are being directed to the NLRB. Three questions top the list:

  1. Of the 10,684 cases moved to determination, how many were dismissed, withdrawn, settled, or resulted in a complaint?
  2. How many FY 2026 dismissals were for failure to cooperate or missed deadlines, as opposed to a finding of no merit?
  3. How many charges are pending today, counting those filed since January 7?

A backlog shrinks when cases are decided well. It also shrinks when fewer cases survive the front door.

Both can be called favorable case processing data. Only one is a remedy for the worker who filed.

The NLRB has told the public the pile got smaller. It has not yet said which kind of smaller.

Fediverse reactions

Advertisements

Discover more from Bureaucracy Times

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.