The Senate Permitting Bill Costs Under $1 Billion, Provided Nobody Asks What Is in It

Flat editorial illustration in muted navy, burgundy, beige, and institutional gray. A large open government ledger or budget document on a desk, with a small dollar sign and a question mark floating above it, suggesting an incomplete accounting. Dry, deadpan newspaper illustration style. No text.

On Friday, the Congressional Budget Office told two senators that the biggest permitting overhaul in a generation would add less than $1 billion to the deficit over ten years. The Senate is expected to hold a final vote this week.

That number will be repeated often. It deserves more scrutiny than it will get.

The estimate is a five-page letter to Budget Committee Chairman Ron Johnson and Ranking Member Jeff Merkley. It is labeled preliminary, and it covers only the conventional budget effects of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. The bill is a 494-page substitute amendment, attached to a House tax bill for survivors of sexual misconduct.

The Senate voted 73 to 25 on November 9 to move it forward. Merkley, one of the two senators who requested the score, voted no.

A Number With No Receipt

The letter offers a ceiling and no arithmetic. There are no gross spending figures, no offsetting receipts, no year-by-year path and no stated assumption about how much faster projects would move.

That may be normal for a preliminary letter. It is still the figure senators will carry onto the floor.

The letter does describe the mechanism. Faster permitting would pull federal spending into the 2027 to 2036 window that would otherwise occur after 2036 “or not at all.” CBO points to unspent Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act balances as an example.

It adds one sentence: some of the accelerated spending would come from funding originally designated as an emergency requirement. It gives no amount.

Compare CBO’s estimate of H.R. 8870, the House surface transportation bill. That document assumed spending would accelerate for 25 percent of affected accounts by about five months. It reported that $1.7 billion of $2.3 billion in accelerated spending came from emergency funds.

That is what showing the work looks like. The permitting letter does not.

Two more admissions sit in the letter. CBO could not determine whether the bill’s mandates on states and the private sector exceed federal thresholds. And the growth effects belong in a dynamic estimate that CBO says it can produce “if requested,” given more time.

The Open Tab at the Treasury

Two sections of the bill create new ways to sue the government for money. The letter mentions neither.

Section 1401 bars agencies from revoking or interfering with permits in effect on or after November 6, 2026. A developer who shows an agency acted in bad faith can recover 25 to 50 percent of its development and construction costs, plus fees and delay costs.

Section 1402 covers more than 40 types of energy projects, from solar and wind to oil, gas, coal, nuclear and hardrock mining. A developer who proves its permits were denied in bad faith, or delayed, as part of a “pattern of disparate treatment” can recover 50 to 100 percent of the project’s expected construction cost.

Both sections pay from the Judgment Fund, a permanent appropriation at the Treasury. Both say payments are “not subject to the availability of appropriations.” The money comes from the Treasury, not from the budget of the agency that lost.

The bill has limits. Payment requires a final court judgment, and a settlement counts only with specific court findings. Section 1402 claims cannot be filed until 180 or 280 days after enactment. The statistical pattern must be a substantial increase over a ten-year baseline and the product of an “intentional course of action.” Supporters will say those bars are high.

The Congressional Research Service raised the scale question in report R49511, written about the bill as introduced. The Judgment Fund averaged about $3.5 billion a year from fiscal 2009 through 2025. Between April and October of this year, it paid about $3.8 billion to settle with ten offshore wind developers over leases Interior later canceled.

CBO’s silence is not proof of an error. The agency may have judged the payouts too unlikely to score. That is an inference, resting on the letter’s silence, and the letter does not say.

The Offset That May Already Be Spoken For

The letter says the bill would raise receipts from energy and mineral production on federal land. Those receipts count as reductions in direct spending. CBO includes hardrock mining receipts from expanding the land eligible for leasing, and says that on net, higher infrastructure spending would exceed the collections.

Section 2215 of the bill does expand hardrock leasing, to federally acquired lands. It also decides where the money goes.

Receipts from those leases would be deposited into a new Abandoned Hardrock Mine Fund. So would a new $400 annual fee on mill sites, though that fee applies only to the extent appropriations acts provide for it. Interior could spend the fund “without further appropriations or fiscal year limitation” on abandoned mine reclamation under the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act.

Money that comes in and goes back out is not a saving. Whether CBO counted the fund’s spending against its receipts, the letter does not say.

That is an inference from Section 2215(d) and CBO’s description of hardrock receipts. CBO may well have netted it out.

Fewer Doors to the Courthouse

CBO says the bill would speed projects by “reducing the likelihood of litigation.” It names two tools: limiting the time to file and limiting who may sue. The text does more than that.

Challenges to environmental reviews, Clean Water Act permits, Endangered Species Act opinions, energy leasing decisions and historic preservation reviews all face a 150-day filing deadline. The rest varies by statute.

Under the new NEPA section, a plaintiff must have commented during the review and allege direct harm. A win yields only a remand, without vacatur or injunction. The permit stays in effect while the agency fixes it.

The Clean Water Act section goes further. A court cannot vacate or enjoin a Section 404 permit unless it finds an imminent and substantial danger to health or the environment with no other equitable remedy. That applies when a court finds the permit violated the Clean Water Act’s own requirements, not only a procedural statute.

Endangered Species Act challenges to biological opinions go only to the D.C. Circuit. For federal actions authorizing use of Tribal trust resources, NEPA claims get no judicial review, except by the Tribe itself or for effects outside trust lands.

Supporters, including the Bipartisan Policy Center, argue that developers win most NEPA suits yet still pay for the uncertainty in higher capital costs. That is a fair argument. It is also an empirical one.

CBO’s own blog post calling for new research on permitting said the agency would benefit from additional linked project-level data. The score rests on a model its authors say needs better evidence.

The questions do not depend on the vote. If the bill advances, this letter will be the number everyone cites. If it stalls, the same text may return. CBO says a fuller estimate is possible if someone asks for one.

Fediverse reactions

Advertisements

Discover more from Bureaucracy Times

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.